How Micrometer-Size Uranium Particles Can Become Suspended in Air and Dispersed by Wind
Leonard A. Dietz
February 19, 1993
Source: http://www.libertyforlife.com/military-war/how_micrometersize_uranium_part.htm
Stokes's law for a sphere falling freely under gravitational attraction
in a viscous medium and the phenomenon of electrostatic attraction are
used to explain how wind action can transport minute particles of
uranium metal or its oxide great distances from where they originate
Environmental assessments for sites which process depleted uranium (DU)
or test fire DU munitions typically downplay the potential for
widespread fallout of DU particles. For example, in one such
environmental impact study {[1]}, the following statement is made:
"Because of the mass and density of the DU particle, it only travels
short distances when airborne. These two factors alone preclude the
off-site release of DU." This statement is untrue for µm-size (1 µm = 1
x 106 meter) particles of uranium metal or its oxide.
In 1979 the author worked at the Knolls Atomic Power Laboratory in
Schenectady, NY. He and his colleagues in the mass spectrometer
component discovered DU aerosols collected in environmental air filters
exposed at the Knolls site, including four particles identified
isotopically as DU {[2]}. A local newspaper {[3]} reported that NL
Industries (National Lead Co.) was fabricating DU penetrators for 30 mm
cannon rounds at their plant 10 miles east of the Knolls site. Deleted
uranium also was measured in air filters exposed at a site 26 miles
north-west of the NL plant. Unrelated to the discover of DU in air
filters, in 1980 NY State forced NL to close, because they exceeded a
state radioactivity limit of 150 microcuries (approximately 387 grams of
DU) for airborne emissions in a given month {[4]}.
Four DU particles in the size range of approximately 4-6 µm (2.5 µm =
0.0001 inch [0,00025 cm]) were extracted from air filters and were
analyzed separately for their uranium isotopic content. All four
particles contained pure depleted uranium. Three of the particles were
irregularly shaped, the fourth was a 3.8-µm diameter sphere. Its
spherical shape indicates that it had solidified from a molten state.
Because uranium metal is pyrophoric, at its melting temperature the
uranium would have become oxidized and then solidified as an uranium
oxide particle, UO2. The density of uranium metal is 19 g/cm3 (grams per
cubic centimeter); for UO2 it is 11 g/cm3 , which is equal to the
density of lead. How can uranium particles with the density of lead or
greater remain airborne long enough to be transported by wind at
distance of 10 miles or more?
Just as a parachute jumper in a free fall through the lower atmosphere
quickly reaches a constant terminal velocity of approximately 120 miles
per hour, so too a µm size uranium particle falling under gravitational
attraction through still air will reach a constant terminal velocity
that is determined by its size, density, geometrical shape and air
viscosity. Stokes's law {[4]} allows one to calculate the terminal
velocity of a micro-sphere of uranium metal or uranium oxide of know
radius and density falling through air. It is given by the expression
Vs = 2 G (Rs)2 (Ds-Dm) / (9 Cv), where
Rs is the radius of the sphere, Ds and Dm are the densities of the
sphere and medium respectively, and Cv is the coefficient of viscosity.
The terminal velocity Vs will be in cm/sec (centimeters per second) if G
is in cm/sec2, Rs is in cm, Ds and Dm are in g/cm3 and Cv is in poises.
According to Gofman {[5]}, a 5 µm uranium particle is approximately the
largest that can become trapped permanently in lung tissue. Constant
bombardment of lung tissue within the short range (about 33-µm in water)
of alpha particles emitted from this size DU particle can produce a very
high yearly radiation dose to this tissue - a radioactive hot spot in
the lung. For a 5-µm diameter UO2 sphere we have
G = 980.4 cm/sec2 is the acceleration due to gravity;
Rs = 2.5 x 104 cm is the radius of the 5 µm uranium oxide sphere;
Ds = 11 g/cm3 is the density of UO2;
Dm = 0.001213 g/cm3 is the density of air at 1 atmosphere and 18°C;
Cv = 1.827 x 104 poise is the viscosity of air at 1 atmosphere and 18°C
Substituting these values into the expression for Stokes's law gives the
calculated terminal velocity Vs of a 5-µm diameter UO2 sphere as Vs =
0.82 cm/sec; in still air it will fall approximately 97 feet in one our
[29,58 m]. A 5-µm diameter sphere of uranium metal falls at 1.42 cm/sec
in air, or approximately 168 feet in one hour [51,24 m] Stokes's law is
valid for fluid flow described by a Reynolds number Re for a sphere is
given by
Re = 2Rs Dm Vs / Cv
where the terms are defined above. For a 5-µm diameter uranium metal
sphere falling at 1.42 cm/sec in air, Re = 0.0047. This value is much
less than the upper limit of 0.1, below which Stokes's law is accurate.
Exhaust air from a DU processing plant is warmer than ambient outside
air and it can raise rapidly several hundred feet above the exhaust
stacks. From Stokes's law, the 3.8 µm diameter UO2 sphere collected at
the Knolls site had a terminal velocity of 0.47 cm/sec, or 56 feet/hour.
It had to reach a height of only 200 feet [61 m] above the NL Industries
plant for a gentle breeze averaging 3 miles per hour toward the west to
carry it 10 miles to the Knolls site. Because irregularly shaped
particles are not streamlined like spheres, they have substantially
lower terminal velocities than spheres of equivalent size and density
and will remain airborne longer and travel farther.
A second and even more effective natural phenomenon can greatly extend
the dispersed range of uranium oxide particles. It is the electrostatic
attraction between dust particles and UO2 particles. Both can become
electrically charged by frictional forces generated by air turbulence.
In addition, a UO2 particle can become highly charged when an alpha
particle from its interior passes through its surface. It is well know
that a high velocity ion striking a metal oxide surface can dislodge 10
or more secondary electrons from the surface {[7]}. An alpha particle is
a high velocity helium ion, and it will generate a large number of
secondary electrons below the surface of an uranium oxide particle as it
passes through the surface. Many of the momentarily free electrons just
below the surface will escape from the particle, leaving it in a
positively charged state. Like an electrostatic precipitator collecting
dust in a room, a charged UO2 particle and an oppositely charged dust
particle will attract each other and join together.
From then on they move as a single particle. Depending on the mass and
density of the dust particle, the average density of both particles
joined together may be only 3-4 grams per cubic centimeter. In the case,
the rate of fall of the UO2 particle is reduced to less than a third of
its former rate and its fallout range is more than tripled.
The preceding discussion explains how µm-size uranium metal and uranium
oxide particles can be dispersed great distances by the wind. In Kuwait,
soot from the large oil fires there probably aided dispersal of depleted
uranium particles throughout the entire Persian Gulf region.
------------------------------------
[1] "Environmental Assessment for the Depleted Uranium Testing Program
at the Nevada Test Site by the United States Army Ballistic Research
Laboratory", US Dept. of Energy, Nevada Field Office, Las Vegas, Nevada.
Report No NV-89-06, March 1992, page 12.
[2] L.A. Dietz, CHEM-434 LAD, "Investigation of Excess Alpha Activity
Observed in Recent Air Filter Collections and Other Environmental
Samples", Jan 24, 1980, unclassified technical report, Knolls Atomic
Power Laboratory, Schenectady, NY 12301; obtained under the Freedom of
Information Act. Copies available upon request from Ms Cathy Hinds,
Director, Military Toxics Project, P.O. Box 845, Sabattus, ME 04280, or
from Ms. Grace Bukowski, Citizen Alert, P.O. Box 5339, Reno, NV 89513.
[3] Schenectady Gazette newspaper: "Colonie Uranium Plant Closes as
Radiation Continues Unchecked", February 6, 1980
[4] B. S. Massey, Mechanics of Fluids, 6th Ed., Van Nostrand Reinhold
(International), page 172, 1989
[5] J. W. Gofman, Radiation and human Health, Sierra Club Books, San
Francisco 1981, page 489
[6] R. W. Fox and A. T. McDonald, Introduction to Fluid Mechanics, 4th
Ed. Wiley, New York, page 444 (1992)
[7] L. A. Dietz and J. C. Sheffield, "Secondary electron emission
induced by 5-30 KeV monatomic ions striking thin oxide films", Journal
of Applied Physics, Vol. 46, No 10, October 1975, page 4361
See also: Wind Carries DU to UK
Nanometer-micrometer sized depleted uranium (DU) particles in the environment https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0265931X19304722
